German Elliott wave services: checking providers and analyses
Distinguish stock3, HKCM, Schulz Technical Analysis, Frank Schuh, Robby and Lirius; record subscription costs and test published scenarios.
Published: (UTC+3)
Русский · English · Deutsch · Español · Français · Italiano · 繁體中文 · 日本語 · 한국어
A German Elliott wave analysis may be a public blog post, newsletter, live commentary or paid analysis package. This comparison identifies publicly described offerings as of 25 October 2026. It contains no personal customer reviews, installed product tests or return ranking. A useful choice starts with the required market, timeframe and an analysis saved before the subsequent move.
stock3: Elliott-Wellen-Trading, authors and live content
The Elliott-Wellen-Trading product page names Sven Weisenhaus and Thomas May, analyses and live sessions. Distinguish this editorial service from the drawing tools in stock3 Terminal and the earlier Guidants name. Manually placing waves on a chart does not itself constitute a subscription to analysts' work.
To assess an actual stock3 experience, preserve the complete analysis before the move: which feed, wave degree and condition would invalidate the scenario? For a webinar, also record its date and recording access. Put introductory terms, regular renewal price, duration and cancellation in one cost record; an offer headline is insufficient.
HKCM: method, packages and scenario conditions
HKCM describes Elliott waves with Fibonacci and market-specific analysis packages. Its FAQ distinguishes packages and individual-asset update frequency. Start the assessment with the selected product: a DAX package does not establish coverage of Bitcoin or gold.
Save the main and alternative scenarios with timestamps. Record target zone and invalidation separately: one describes an expected area, the other rejects the selected count under a defined condition. If a sample analysis is available, check these fields and compare later revisions with the original. Advertising and isolated successful calls do not replace a complete evaluation.
Identify Schulz Technical Analysis and STA Solutions
The public STA portal describes selectable analysis subscriptions, including Bitcoin and Ethereum, combining Elliott analysis with other technical indicators. Use the full Schulz Technical Analysis name and linked domain when a search for STA Solutions returns multiple services.
Compare identical instruments and observation windows. A long-term daily or weekly chart answers a different question from a short-term update. For comparison with HKCM, record written analysis, optional video, updates for the individual asset and the total price of the selected combination. A public product description establishes the format, not independently tested trading performance.
Frank Schuh, Robby and Lirius: identify the actual source
ElliottWaver.live identifies Frank Schuh as its author. Robby's Elliottwellen and the Lirius blog are separate publishing sources; no civil identity is inferred from a pseudonym here. The publisher's identification of Phantom and Florian Winter belongs to the book and does not identify either blogger.
For a blog, retain the specific article, publication time and version available before the price move. Separate the author's text from readers' comments. Two articles may discuss DAX using different feeds or timeframes and therefore different levels. Check the underlying data before deciding that both authors answered the same question differently.
Compare free analyses, subscriptions and reported experiences
Choose a task first, such as a daily DAX count with a documented alternative. A free blog, newsletter and live trading become comparable only after scope, delay and archive access are known. Calculate the entire contract period, including necessary data or platform charges, and record renewal and cancellation from current terms.
For your own assessment, select a continuous period in advance and keep every scenario, including discarded alternatives. Score clarity, delivery and traceable revisions separately from hypothetical trading results. A profit calculation also requires predefined execution and costs; a target area that looks appropriate afterwards is insufficient.
| Check | Save beforehand | Evaluate afterwards |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | Asset, feed, timeframe, scope | Was that exact task delivered? |
| Scenario | Wave points, alternative, invalidation | Which previously stated condition occurred? |
| Cost | Full period, extras, renewal | Cost for the service actually used |
| Experience | Every dated version in the period | Successes, failures and revisions together |
A provider shows a correct target zone but only a subsequently revised chart. Does that establish its hit rate?
No. Without a preserved earlier version and a defined population of forecasts, neither the original prediction time nor a hit rate can be established reliably.